Table of Contents | Message Board | Printable Version
Hythloday's Visit to England
Hythloday continues with his reasons why he refuses to put himself into the service of the king by providing an example of how easy it is for the monarch to adhere to laws that are unjust. Some time ago he had visited England and stayed with Cardinal Morton. While there he had dinner with the Cardinal and a lawyer who was incredulous that despite the number of thieves hanged, there seemed to be no decrease in cases of stealing. He did not see how such a superb justice system could continue to produce thieves. Hythloday replied that this did not surprise him since it was food that most people were after and therefore they had to steal in order to survive. Then Hythloday listed the causes of why people became thieves by citing unemployment in England. Wounded soldiers who could find no work; disbanded retainers of a rich lord who had no qualifications; and peasants displaced from their age-old fields due to the great demand for sheep pastures could not even depend on the generosity of alms houses and monasteries because the high cost of food made it difficult for these places to be of help. These men and women therefore had to steal.
Morton was very upset by Hythloday's statement and asked him how he would handle the situation. Hythloday had quoted the example of the Romans who made their prisoners work in quarries. These men paid off their debts by working for the state. Many of those who at the table did not agree with Hythloday until they realized that the Cardinal endorsed his ideas and then they also agreed. When a wag asked if those who were unable to engage themselves in any work due to old age or illness should be put into monasteries and nunneries, the Cardinal smiled at the joke but it was misunderstood as an approval and was seconded by all present there.